A Study of the Retention-of-Title Clause in Imami Jurisprudence and Iranian Law and Its Role in Securing the Seller’s Rights in Contracts of Sale
Keywords:
Retention-of-title clause, seller’s rights, installment sale, risk management, Imami jurisprudence, Iranian lawAbstract
The retention-of-title clause, as one of the effective instruments for securing the seller’s rights in contracts of sale, suspends the transfer of ownership of the sold property until the full payment of the price. This clause plays an important role in deferred-payment and installment sales by protecting the seller’s financial rights, managing risks associated with the buyer’s default or bankruptcy, and reducing legal disputes between the parties. In Imami jurisprudence, the legitimacy of this clause is grounded in principles such as the obligation to fulfill contractual conditions, the rule of dominion, and the no-harm rule. In Iranian law, the retention-of-title clause is also recognized as valid by reference to Article 10 of the Civil Code and the principle of freedom of contract, although gaps such as the absence of official registration for this clause have created limitations in its enforcement. In addition, in comparative legal systems such as those of France and Germany, the official registration of the retention-of-title clause contributes to stronger protection of the seller’s rights against third parties. This study was conducted with the aim of analyzing the jurisprudential and legal foundations of this clause, examining its challenges, and proposing practical solutions to improve its enforcement in the Iranian legal system.
Downloads
References
1. Sanami H, editor Granting additional time for performance of the obligations of the seller and buyer and its effects. 13th International Conference on Religious and Islamic Studies, Law, Educational Sciences, and Psychology; 2024.
2. Raeisi M, Ali Akbari E, editors. A study of the seller's obligations in the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods and its comparison with Iranian law and Shiite jurisprudence. International Comprehensive Congress of Iranian Law; 2016.
3. Khalifehpourmianji M, Razi M, Yousefi H. Retention-of-Title Clause. Tehran: Nikvarzan Publications; 2024.
4. Farahmandian M, editor Legal challenges of immediate transfer of ownership: Retention-of-title clause. 3rd International Conference on Advocacy, Law, and Humanities; 2024.
5. Sourgoli S, editor A study of the foundations and concepts of ownership in Iranian law. 7th International Conference on Innovation and Research in Law, Political Science, and Islamic Studies; 2025; Tehran, Iran.
6. Ghadiri Darbandi R, editor A study of the effects of the retention-of-title clause in Iranian law. 1st International Conference on Law, Political Science, Islamic Politics, and Islamic Jurisprudence; 2024.
7. Mohseni Sani M, Abbaszadeh Z, editors. A study of the status of the retention-and-reservation-of-ownership clause in Iranian law. 2nd National Conference on Fundamental Jurisprudential and Legal Studies; 2023.
8. Alizadeh A, Hosseini Vardenjani SMT. Legal status of transactions conflicting with a negative result condition in Imami jurisprudence and Iranian law. Ghazavat Journal. 2024;24(118).
9. Mahdavi M, editor Retention-of-title clause in English law and the right of retention in Iranian law. 14th International Conference on Law and Judicial Sciences; 2023; Tehran, Iran.
10. Mashayekhi S, Adabi H. The place of the retention-of-title clause in the law of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Nations Research. 2019(42).
11. Abdolkhani H. A comparative study of the retention-of-title clause in Iranian law and Sunni jurisprudence: Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz; 2012.
12. Al-Zuhairi TMK. The legal nature and effects of the retention-of-title clause in the contract of sale. Journal of Human and Natural Sciences. 2024;5(2).
13. Al-Jarrah J. Effects of the retention-of-title clause against third parties under Law No. 20 of 2018 on securing rights relating to movable property: A comparative study. Jordan Journal of Law and Political Science. 2023;15(2).
14. Kulthum BQ. The effectiveness of the retention-of-title clause as a special guarantee in protecting commercial credit. Journal of Legal and Political Research. 2018;2(10).
15. Bahrami Khoshkar M, Hosseini Yekta SS, Sayadi S. A study of the theoretical root of the specificity of the sold object in the Iranian legal system and Imami jurisprudence. Safir-e Noor. 2022;16(45).
16. Rasekh H. Obligations of the seller and buyer in the contract of sale: Ibn Sina University; 2023.
17. Mirki M, Karami F, Zanganeh Shahraki J, editors. Analysis of the legal status of arsh after waiver of the option for defect in Islamic jurisprudence and Iranian law. 19th Call for Works of the Khorasan Seminary; 2024.
18. Alizadeh AH, Parsapour MB. Foundations of deprivation of ownership in Imami jurisprudence, Iranian law, and English law with emphasis on judicial practice. Modares Humanities, Comparative Law Research. 2021;25(4).
19. Rajaei F, Aziz SM. Comparison of buyer and seller remedies in Imami jurisprudence and Iranian law with resale of goods in the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (Vienna 1980). Civil Law Knowledge. 2019;2(2).
20. Azizi H. Effects of delay in payment of the price on transfer of ownership in Iranian civil law. Modern Law Quarterly. 2020;6(3):121-40.
21. Lotfi A. Civil Procedure Code: With Explanatory Notes on Articles 295 to 441. Tehran: Verseh Publications; 2022.
22. Kalhor S, Shoja Sangchouli M. A comparative study of the effect of a sale contract with floating price in Iranian positive law and the 1980 Vienna Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods. Law and Modern Studies. 2024;5(2).
23. Joudaki M, editor The sanction for breach of the obligation to pay the price in the Iranian legal system and the English Sale of Goods Act. 11th International and National Conference on Management, Accounting, and Law Studies; 2024.
24. Shamshiri A, Ghasemi H, editors. A study of futures contracts in Imami jurisprudence and Iranian legal foundations. 7th National Conference on New Horizons in Humanities, Economics, and Entrepreneurship; 2023.
25. Goli AP, Mashayekhi A, editors. Study and analysis of the rehabilitation system in the law of the Islamic Republic of Iran and the common-law and Romano-Germanic legal systems. 7th International Conference on Innovation and Research in Law, Political Science, and Islamic Studies; 2025.
26. Rasouli M. Jurisprudential-legal analysis of the retention-of-title clause in salam and deferred-payment sales. Islamic Jurisprudence and Law Research. 2023;18(2):45-68.
27. Aghaei N, Mazaheri Kouhanestani R. Retention-of-title clause in sale contracts: A comparative study in Iranian and English law. Legal Journal, University of Isfahan. 2018;5(7).
28. Madani SJ. Civil Law: Named Contracts. Tehran: Paydar Publications; 2013.
29. Ahangaran MR. A jurisprudential and legal rereading of the principle of binding force in contracts. Islamic Law Research Journal. 2018(48).
30. Zahiri A. A study of the retention-of-title clause in the contract of sale: Shahid Ashrafi Isfahani Higher Education Institute; 2014.
31. Yazdani G. Retention-of-Title Clause: A Comparative View of Imami Jurisprudence and English, French, and German Law: Razavi University of Islamic Sciences Press; 2016.
Downloads
Published
Submitted
Revised
Accepted
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Tayebeh Safi (Author); Ali Chahkandinezhad; Hasan Ghowth (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
