The Governance System in Contemporary Iraq: From Institutional Fragility to the Prospect of Smart Governance
Keywords:
governance, Iraq, historical analysis, political–social changeAbstract
Political and institutional developments in Iraq after 2003 have demonstrated that weak governance structures, systemic corruption, the inefficiency of supervisory institutions, and ethno-sectarian divisions have been among the main challenges to the continuity of the state in this country. This study examines the pathology of Iraq’s governance system, focusing on the incomplete democratic transition, elite empowerment processes, and the destructive effects of foreign actors’ interventions. The governmental structure based on ethnic and sectarian quota allocation (muhasasa), although initially designed as a mechanism for inclusion and participation, has in practice led to the strengthening of sectarian identities over national interests, the weakening of the rule of law, and the emergence of a rent-seeking and corruption-based political economy. The analysis of the current situation reveals that Iraq faces a profound paradox: the coexistence of formal democratic structures alongside informal and quasi-state governance. Ultimately, this article outlines a vision for transitioning toward smart governance as a means to enhance transparency, accountability, and institutional efficiency in Iraq, and proposes strategies to reduce dependency on quota-based governance models.
Downloads
References
1. Ahmadi K. Iraq after the Fall of Baghdad. Tehran: Center for Political and International Studies, Ministry of Foreign Affairs; 2011.
2. Akbari H. The Crisis of Sovereignty in Iraq. Tehran: Andisheh Sazan-e Nour Publishing; 2014.
3. Al-Rasheed M. The Fiefdom State: Governing Iraq after the Fall of Saddam. New York: Oxford University Press; 2017.
4. Faleh A. Incomplete Democratization and Sectarianization of the Iraqi State. Middle Eastern Studies. 2019;55(4):610-28.
5. Khosravi GR. The Prospect of Future Iraq: A Review of Internal and External Trends. Tehran: Strategic Research Institute with the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance; 2018.
6. International Crisis G. Iraq’s Looming Economic Crisis and the Future of State Capture. International Crisis Group, 2021.
7. Nia RE. A Pathological Study of the Political System and Governance in Iraq. Brazilian Journal of Law & International Relations. 2022;4(37).
8. Baz BA. The Role of E-Government in Administrative Decision-Making and Electronic Voting. Cairo: Dar al-Kutub al-Qanuniyya; 2019.
9. Rotberg RI. Good Governance Means Performance and Results. Governance. 2014;27(3):511-8.
10. Keping Y. Governance and Good Governance: A New Framework for Political Analysis. Fudan Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences. 2018;11(1):1-8.
11. Ansell C, Torfing J. Handbook on Theories of Governance. 2022.
12. Najafi F, Masoudnia H, Emamjomehzadeh SJ, Nassaj H. Federalism and the Triangle of Power (Shiites, Kurds, and Sunnis) in the Political Structure of the New Iraq. Contemporary Political Essays. 2016;19:141-69.
13. Eyvazi MR, Marzban N, Salehi M. From Reviewing Good Governance to a Sustainable Governance Model. Rahbord (Strategy Quarterly). 2017;26:99-136.
14. Stojanović I, Ateljević J, Stević RS. Good Governance as a Tool of Sustainable Development. European Journal of Sustainable Development. 2016;5(4):558-.
15. Haliah, Nirwana. The Development of Good Governance Model for Performance Improvement. International Journal of Excellence in Government. 2019;1(1):21-36.
16. Davis TJ. Good Governance as a Foundation for Sustainable Human Development in Sub-Saharan Africa. Third World Quarterly. 2017;38(3):636-54.
17. Ighoshemu BO, Ogidiagba UB. Poor Governance and Massive Unemployment in Nigeria: As Causes of Brain Drain in the Buhari Administration (2015–2020). Insights into Regional Development. 2022;4(2):73-84.
18. Buraqai A. Governance Indicators According to the World Bank. Beirut: Al-Dar al-Jami'iyah; 2018.
19. Transparency I. Corruption Perceptions Index 2022: Iraq Country Profile. Berlin: Transparency International, 2023.
20. Yazdani Zazerani MR. Examining the Conceptual Relation and the Impact of Governance on Public Policy. International Relations Research Quarterly. 2017(80):99-136.
21. Kooiman J. Governing and Governing Capacities. London: Sage Publications; 2003.
22. Ebrahimi A. Pathology of the Supervisability of Supreme Councils in Light of Good Governance Principles. Tehran: University of Tehran; 2021.
23. Zanini MT, Migueles CP. Trust as an Element of Informal Coordination and Its Relationship with Organizational Performance. 2013:77-93.
24. Gritsenko D, Wood M. Algorithmic Governance: A Modes of Governance Approach. Regulation & Governance. 2022;16(1):45-62.
25. Bjørnskov C, Voigt S. Why Do Governments Call a State of Emergency? On the Determinants of Using Emergency Constitutions. European Journal of Political Economy. 2018;54:110-23.
26. Nipa MN, Hasan M. The Role of Civil Society in Promoting Good Governance: A Qualitative Inquiry into Bangladesh’s Experience. Socio Economy and Policy Studies. 2023;3(2):91-7.
27. Innerarity D. Artificial Intelligence and Democracy. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), 2024.
28. World B. Iraq: Governance and Anti-Corruption Assessment. Washington, DC: World Bank, 2020.
29. Abu al-Hawa NMA. The Liability of the Administration to Compensate for Illegal Administrative Decisions. Amman: Middle East University; 2010.
30. Taha AA. Legislation of Decentralization in Administration and Governance in Iraq: Salahaddin University, College of Law and Politics; 2015.
31. Ahmadi FA, Ghazvini Y. The Process of Drafting Iraq’s Constitution. Politics Quarterly (Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran). 2010;40:19-37.
32. Al-Naqeeb A. The General Theory of Liability Arising from the Personal Act (Fault and Damage). 3 ed. Beirut: Oueidat Publications; 2015.
33. Ebrahimi NA. Outlook on the Relations of Arab Countries with the New Iraq. Strategic Studies Quarterly. 2010;10:40-69.
34. Sardarnia K. Ethical Civil Society, Human Rights, and Good Governance. Political-Economic Quarterly. 2010(280):236-69.
35. Saleh AM. The Criminal Protection of Internal State Security: Al-Mustansiriya University; 2012.
36. Boutros Z. Encyclopedia of Local Governance, Vol. 1. Cairo: Nahdet Misr Press; 2016.
37. Sa'sa I. Administrative Regional Decentralization in Iraq. Journal “Message of Rights” (College of Law). 2011;3(1):12-29.
38. Khidr K. The Diversity of Civil Liability into Contractual and Tortious and the Choice Between Them in Egyptian Civil Law Compared with French Law. Journal of Law and Economics. 2010;2(1):15-39.
39. Kleider H. Multilevel Governance: Identity, Political Contestation, and Policy. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations. 2020;22(4):792-9.
40. Jaballah ALH. The Impact of Electronic Means on the Legality of Administrative Acts. Alexandria: Dar al-Fikr al-Jami'i; 2013.
41. Jungherr A. Artificial Intelligence and Democracy: A Conceptual Framework. Social Media + Society. 2023;9(3).
Downloads
Published
Submitted
Revised
Accepted
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Ali Khalaf Turki Al-Gburi (Author); Mohammad Sharif Shahi; Saad Abdullah Khalaf, Zainab Pourkhaqan Shahrezaee (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
